OPINION: UK-Africa trade and investment: who benefits?
News24
24 Jan 2020, 16:14 GMT+10
There has been much hype about a major Africa investment summit being hosted by the UK. Attended by Prime Minister Boris Johnson and an array of royals, a great deal of hopeful win-win-win rhetoric abounded linked to forging new partnerships for a post-Brexit future.
At the summit, Ghana, it seems, is being given top treatment as a favoured destination, while Zimbabwe appears to have been snubbed despite being "open for business".
UK aid policy these days is focused on promoting UK trade interests abroad, with the government adopting a global business promotion approach for UK firms.
The linking of aid and trade, of course, has a history in Britain. In 1994 the Pergau dam scandal – in which aid was used as a sweetener for an arms deal – led to the commitment to untie aid. It also led to the establishment of a separate development department and an Act of Parliament specifying how aid must be spent.
This consensus on aid since the mid-1990s, however, is now under threat.
Trade and investment can of course help reduce poverty, promote women's empowerment and be good for children's rights. But the opposite may be true too. There are many different business models – and so labour, environmental and rights regimes – with very different outcomes. We've been looking at some of these issues over the last few years across a number of projects. All were funded by the UK's Department for International Development.
The project compared three broad types of commercial agricultural investment: estates and plantations; medium-scale commercial farms; and outgrower schemes. The team looked at each business model in Ghana, Kenya and Zambia, examining the outcomes for land, labour, livelihoods and so on.
Cases included investments with UK-linked companies such the much-feted Blue Skies company in Ghana, which packages and exports fruit produced by smallholder outgrowers. Another was the rather bizarre sugar outgrower scheme in Zambia, operated by Illovo, which is now largely owned by British Foods, whereby smallholders' land is incorporated into an estate and they are paid revenues for the use of land.
The findings showed that the "terms of incorporation" into business arrangements really mattered. Too often estates or plantations operated as "enclaves" separated from the local community; some provided employment opportunities but frequently with poor conditions. Smallholder-led outgrower arrangements, where influence over terms was effective, had substantial linkage effects with the local community.
A decade ago, at the height of Africa's land rush, many investments were deemed to be "land grabs". But our work argued for a more nuanced assessment. Not all investments are bad. But not all are good either. Linking investment to the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation's "Voluntary Guidelines" is essential. This allows investors, governments and recipient communities to make balanced appraisals, avoiding investment riding roughshod over local land rights and livelihoods.
Hidden networks
Another project, part of the Agricultural Policy in Africa programme, has focused on agricultural investment corridors in Kenya (LAPSSET), Tanzania (SAGCOT) and Mozambique (Beira and Nacala). Alongside Chinese, Brazilian and other investors, UK investments are evident in all sites.
Again, our findings highlight the design of these corridor investments and the importance of a "networked" approach in which there are multiple linkages from the core investments (usually around infrastructure, large estates and mining) to the wider hinterland. Too often extractive "tunnel" designs emerge in which any impacts on wider development are very limited.
Our conclusions are reflected in AGRA's excellent 2019 report focusing on the "hidden middle". This argues that the private sector investment with the most impact is usually small, often informal, and deeply linked into local economies. Clusters of interconnected economic activity are usually spontaneous, not planned as part of grand corridor or investment hub schemes. And when you look, the link between the vast number of smallholder producers and consumers is increasingly filled with many entrepreneurial private sector actors working in transport, processing, logistics and so on.
Private sector players are not missing in these instances, as is often assumed, but instead hidden from view. The UK-Africa summit's focus on "investment" and the "private sector" emphasises large, formal operations, branded as UK plc. But it is the smaller, local outfits that are driving change in African agricultural value chains. They are the ones in need of support and investment.
Will the focus of the UK Africa investment summit be on supporting such smaller initiatives with the real potential for transformation, and developmental gains? From what I have seen, I somehow doubt it.
What to guard against
As the UK scrambles to compensate for the errors of committing to Brexit, it will be crucial to hold to the UK government to account for its aid spending to avoid business imperatives overriding development goals, with larger UK investors getting the upper hand and crowding out local alternatives.
Investing is certainly possible in ways that are positive for local economies and where land rights are protected in line with internationally-agreed guidelines. But it does require a sophisticated approach that goes beyond the promotional gloss and the hype of international trade fairs. There's plenty of good research on the implications of trade and investment on development in Africa, including that commissioned by DfID. Let's hope the arm of the UK government that is promoting trade makes use of it.
Watch latest videos
Subscribe and Follow
Get a daily dose of Zimbabwe Star news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
News RELEASES
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Zimbabwe Star.
More Information 
35 ℉ Light Snow in Madison
International
Section
Pentagon confirms 34 U.S. service members injured in missile attack
WASHINGTON, DC – Thirty-four U.S. service members have been diagnosed with concussion and traumatic brain injuries as a result of …
Coronavirus spreading rapidly, 13 Chinese cities now in lockdown
BEIJING, China – The death toll and infected rate from the Wuhan coronavirus in China has increased dramatically, while the …
U.S. Senate moves to second phase of Trump trial
WASHINGTON, DC – Democratic prosecutors on Friday wrapped up three days of arguments for seeking Donald Trump's removal from office, …
Turkish earthquake caused scores of casualties, interior minister says
ANKARA, Turkey – The death toll from Friday's powerful earthquake which struck in eastern Turkey keeps rising, the country's interior …
New cases of hog virus reported on Philippine island of Luzon
LINGAYEN, Pangasinan, Jan. 24 (PIA) – As China is grappling to contain an outbreak of coronavirus, in the Philippipines, the …
Queen Elizabeth grants Royal Assent to Brexit Bill
LONDON, UK – Britain Prime Minister Boris Johnson's Brexit bill finally became law after receiving royal assent from Queen Elizabeth …
Africa
Section
New cases of hog virus reported on Philippine island of Luzon
LINGAYEN, Pangasinan, Jan. 24 (PIA) – As China is grappling to contain an outbreak of coronavirus, in the Philippipines, the …
Autopax unable to pay employees full January salaries
Autopax, the operator of Translux and City to City buses, won't be able to pay its employees full salaries for …
Du Preez brothers help Sale sink table-toppers Exeter
London – South African brothers Robert and Daniel du Preez contributed 12 of Sale Sharks' points in their 22-19 victory …
SA U19s book quarter-final spot with DLS win over UAE
Cape Town – Another dominant display with the bat from Bryce Parsons, with good support from Luke Beaufort, was the …
SA sinking ? but scrapper Nortje shifts to A-tier
Cape Town – If the Proteas looked largely like occupants of a tented camp about to be shambolically flattened by …
R5m in counterfeit goods seized in Durban Central
KwaZulu-Natal police have seized R5m worth of counterfeit goods, during an operation in the Durban Central area on Friday."The operation …
Movie Review
